Just when he was about to report on his finishing replicating Roobert33's design,
CLaNZeR's website is closed "until further notice", and his replication
videos have been made private.
It turns out that the inventor is Robert H. Calloway, who says it has been
running continuously. Rotation data posted.
Back on November 18, I posted a feature page at PESWiki about a "Mechanical Opener for V-Gate Magnet Motor - A video originally posed by Roobert33 shows a V-gate magnet motor that supposedly is made functional (rotation maintained) by means of a mechanical method for moving the stator magnets in and out of the way of the gate
('re-gauging') so that the gate doesn't become a lock-up point that otherwise would stop the motion of the magnet motor."
Gratefully, Stefan Hartmann and I grabbed a copy of the video
and posted it on our accounts before Roobert33 deleted the original from his
While the design makes a lot of sense for those of us who believe that magnets
can be arranged to provide primary power (e.g. a rotational device from the
power of magnetism alone), the community was thrown off by Roobert33 saying he
had posted it as a joke. However, quite a few of us, myself included,
tended to think that he may have been saying that out of frustration and a weird
mechanism of self-defense (or self-sabotage); and that the design was probably
CLaNZeR was Nearly Done Replicating It
One of those who saw promise in this design was one of the best free energy
replicators in the world, CLaNZeR
from the UK, who was in process of replicating it, and was giving updates as he
went along. Like always, it was gorgeous work.
I posted a feature
page about CLaNZeR on November 20, 2010, as he was toying with the idea of
providing custom CNC milling services to the free energy community. I
posted links to many of the replications he's been involved with.
On December 10, 2010 6:31 AM MST, CLaNZeR wrote to me:
Last weekend I spent cutting out coloured acrylic signs for my partners new
shop sign, as well as sitting around the Airport for 9 hours trying to get
home! This weekend will be taken up mostly by putting all the Xmas lights up
outside before flying back upto work again for next week.
But will try and get the Relica finished, I need to add looser sliders and cut
out the Cam and then can give it a go.
The accompanying video that he posted said: "Mounted V-Track on the
Rotor and made the uprights. Next the top bar and cam to be added."
Then today I was contacted by Steve Marshall of Los Angeles with several key
pieces of information that shed light on who Roobert33 is, as well as some
alarming information about the status of CLaNZeR's replication.
This isn't just hearsay. Most of this stuff can be immediately verified by
clicking on the links provided.
CLaNZeR Shut Down?
First, take a look at CLaNZeR's website: http://overunity.org.uk
It's down! It says "Offline until further notice."
[On the morning of Dec. 28, 6:30 am MST, I checked again, and now it reads:
"Sorry Overunity.org.uk is Offline till the New Year."]
Steve said that one of the last posts in the comments section, if not the last
post by CLaNZeR stated: "It is easy when you know how, just do not let
others know how."
Now here is the kicker. Go to http://web.archive.org/web/*/http://www.overunity.org.uk
It shows 0 results for 2009 and 2010. (backup
screen grab) Usually the archive.org content is current to about six
months back. I've been to CLaNZeR's site many times over those two years, and I know
that there was plenty of stuff there to be indexed at archive.org. Even
when nothing changes, archive.org grabs copies at regular intervals. Someone
seems to have ordered that material to be removed.
He had a lot of recent
material up. Here
is a screen shot of what is now the most recent version of his site as of July
[December 28 7:30 AM MST update: Archive.org appears to be having some technical
difficulties in general. The info from 2009-2010 is missing from any search
And if you click on the two Roobert33 replication videos he had posted, they
have been made private.
What's going on?!!
I sent CLaNZeR an email asking him about this, and I'll let you know when he has
Response from CLaNZeR
On December 28, 2010 6:07 AM MST, I received the following response from CLaNZeR
Subject: RE: what's up with your site?
Everything fine this end, I took the site down over the Xmas period to have a break from the emails that flood in from people.
Need to do some family time and a few other things popped up.
The site will be back online after the New Year.
Finishing the V-Track is top of the list to do this break, but other unexpected things got in the way and family has to come first this season.
And here is something he wrote to someone else on December 15:
Thanks for the compliments.
I did on plan on finishing the V-Track by swapping out the linear slides and
cutting out the Cam two weekends ago, but as I work away from home 5 days a
week, with the run up to Xmas my weekends have been tied up doing normal stuff
and not had time to finish it.
After this week I am on Xmas break, so hopefully then I will get it finished and
post the results.
The response to me offering CNC services has gone crazy with a Mailbox full of inquiries
that I have not had time to get around to; and hence at the moment I cannot
reply to your question of cost, but the flexible V-Track has gathered a lot of
interest and may be the first project I will plan to cutout and sell on as such.
I will pop your email into the CNC folder and hopefully get around to replying
to everyone for their personal needs sooner than later.
Have a great Xmas that end.
Roobert33 is Robert H. Calloway
Steve also told me that he had just talked to Robert Calloway of Texas, USA,
and that "he is Roobert33". Robert has been working on magnet
motors for years, as can be seen from his website: http://www.CallowayEngines.com
According to Steve, Robert told him "it works perfect" and that it has
been running continuously for "several weeks". "It's
lighting a light in front of me right now."
He also gave him some input about the device, saying that all the key components
are magnets in attraction mode. He said the top bar could be iron, but it
wouldn't have as much power.
Click to see enlarged
screen grab from Calloway's V
Track Motor page on his site as of December 27, 2010.
Going to Robert's website, he has posted the animated gif (that I created for
our coverage) in the upper-left hand portion of the header of his site.
And from the home page, you'll see a link
to this V-gate design. The brief description on that page that is titled,
V Track Motor, states:
"Nobody seems to believe anything. The V Track motor will work by
lifting the stator magnet above the sticky spot using a ramp cam mechanism.
But the lever on the bottom plate raises a magnet by the same cam to assist in
pulling at the start of the V magnets on the rotor wheel. The mechanical gate
assembly is also supported by a spring which assists in lifting the gate. It
is a complete attraction design. This gives the rotor wheel enough speed and
power to overcome lifting the stator magnet. Notice the video at the upper
left. This same principle can be applied to a PFI application. I have talked
about this extensively on this website. There is even more advances to this
design by using up to 4 stator magnets to help get through the sticky spot. It
will be interesting to see how the laws of physics will explain this."
Steve said that Robert bemoaned that people didn't believe that this was
I don't know why he should wonder. Robert is the one who said he had just
done it as a joke, and was sorry it got out of hand. What does he expect?
He did a similar thing back in February of 2006, as documented in a story
I posted here at PESN about his open source magnet motor project based on the
Perendev design, calling it an intentional wild goose chase. That is what
he later told me it was. Apparently that was a deflection as well, from
something that may have been real after all.
When I phoned Robert today, he said he wasn't Roobert33, that he didn't want me
using his name in this story, that he had no further comments for me, given how
I had represented him in the past. Yet even in that very call he was
obviously lying in saying he wasn't Roobert33. It is clear in looking at
his website that he is the inventor of that design. And his flip-flopping
on his story about the recent V-Track design is also consistent with how he has
behaved in the past. Some inventors are eccentric and haven't learned
fundamental social skills, becoming their own worst enemy.
So why did people say this recent V-Gate mechanical over-ride design was a
hoax? For one, the inventor said it was a hoax; though not everyone
believed that, including me and CLaNZeR and Steve.
Time for the Hydra Effect
Well now with CLaNZeR's shutting his site down after being so close to having
this replicated, and the Wayback machine erasing two years of backlogs from his
site, and CLaNZeR making his videos private, and saying "It is easy when
you know how; just do not let others know how"; I'd say it's time to up the
ante and see a whole slew of replications of this design come forward.
As I told Steve, "Once the scientific community realizes that magnets
really can be arranged in such a way as to provide base load power, their minds
will be opened, and a flood of creativity will result; and the world will see a
whole slew of amazing designs come forward."
Steve expects to have his replication done within 3-4 days, and he is
more than happy to share how he did it, and to post photos and videos and
schematics and materials lists so that others can do the same. He said he
has dropped everything to work on this. He can be reached by email at email@example.com
or by phone at 424-634-9963.
We will be posting that as it becomes available -- or your design.
The main reason I launched PESWiki back in 2005 was to provide a publicly
editable site to facilitate such open source projects. Together, the
community can post clear and concise designs, materials sourcing for various
regions of the globe, translations, replication documentation, quantification
and optimization, improvements, kits availability, and completed units
The home page for this open source project is: Directory:_Mechanical_Opener_for_V-Gate_Magnet_Motor
And even though Robert H. Calloway denied being Roobert33 to me today,
let's be sure that he gets his fair share of any revenues generated from
this project (such as from plans sales, kits, completed units,
manufacturing licensing, etc..).
Remember CLaNZeR's last statement: "It is easy when you know how," but
as for the last part of his statement: "...just do not let
others know how"; let's show him that there is safety in numbers.
Remember the scene from
A Bug's Life, where the grasshoppers point out that if the ants ever
realized their strength and how they outnumber the oppressing grasshoppers,
their gig would be up.
Fresh Data in from LightRider
Last month, when this video was posted by Roobert33, I asked LightRider if he
wouldn't mind analyzing the video. This evening, after posting the above
story, he sent me an email with his results:
I have done a speed analysis of this video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bssBAb6EzM4
This is only Raw data. Time vs RGB tracking region of the video (automatic analysis)
Based on these data, the RPM seems to be 115 RPM
A rapid acceleration and constant speed for the rest of the video.
No variation Mylow (type).
The possibility of an external power source must not be rejected at this time.
Looking at the graph, I asked him if he didn't mean "120" RPM, to
which he responded:
No, I mean 115 rpm.
The graphic contains 106 spikes for 55 sec, each rise represents a revolution, this give us 115 RPM for 60 sec (106 * 60sec / 55sec = 115.6 RPM)
Or from the Excel data that come from the RGB tracking... it take 0.52 sec for one revolution... this give us 115 RPM (60sec/0.52=115.4 RPM)
PESWiki Down for Nearly 2 Hours
On December 28 from ~4:16 am to 6:02 am MST, PESWiki was down.
I've asked the server host to tell me what was up with that. The site
rarely goes down. The timing here is suspicious.
At 12:13 PM MST our host responded: "It was a problem upstream provider switch. It has been replaced."
[Note from Dec. 28, 12:25 pm MST]
So it looks like our concerns were mostly unfounded. CLaNZeR is just
taking a break (he will probably have an increase rather than decrease in email
volume, though, from people wondering what is up), Archive.org is experiencing a
general issue, and PESWiki coincidentally experienced a technical glitch.
This morning, CLaNZeR sent a link to the following "quick
update video" at 7:22 AM MST:
He also embedded the above video on the home page of his site, after the
statement: "Sorry Overunity.org.uk is Offline till the New Year."
At 9:10 am MST, I responded:
Thanks for the update.
Here are some of my observations, some of which you also noted in the video:
1) Your cam shape needs improvement. Note that Robert's cam is gradual, followed by the rapid drop. Yours is sudden, with a flat plateau portion, which will contribute to too long of a dwell-time. I'd try to replicate Robert's cam shape the best I could. Your cam almost looks circular, whereas his is
more parabolic or logarithmic.
2) Your up-down sliders have way too much drag. There should be no horizontal angling as it goes up and down. Horizontal angling contributed to huge frictional losses. Note that on Robert's up-and-down mechanism, the rod on the right is very long, and holds the 90-degree horizontal piece straight very well. The long upright contributes to less friction, because leverage isn't nearly so great across such a long piece, compared to the short segment in yours. His friction on that component is very low.
3) On Robert's there is no vertical component on the far side of the 90-degree horizontal piece. There is only a slot to act as a guide to keep it from swinging left or right.
4) I take it you've not yet gotten to building the bottom flipper yet.
As for his calling "rubbish" the hype of his site going down and
archives being missing from Archive.org and videos being made private, I would
remind him that we are in an industry where suppression
is part of the legacy. What does he expect when he pulls down his site
with no other explanation than "Offline 'till further notice" and
makes his videos private?
I seriously doubt these measures contributed to less email load on his part,
which was his objective.
December 30 Update from CLaNZeR
On December 30, 2010 9:59 AM MST, CLaNZeR sent the following message:
This email is sent to all members of overunity.org.uk
Just a quick email to wish everyone all the best for 2011 and to let you know
that the forums are now back online.
They have been upgraded to Vbulletin Version 4.x also, so if you have any
problems or spot any bugs, then please let me know.
The point of the last 2 videos was to follow up on some of the comments in certain forums, to show that using magnets to push the rise bar up or to use pivoting etc etc all have their pitfalls.
Sticking to the original design is still on the cards and will indeed be working on it over the next few weekends to try and get it as close as I can to the original.
If I can get rid of this hangover I may even try to get out in the workshop later today LOL
# # #
In addition to the comments section found below, the following came in by other
Related to Kedron Approach
On December 28, 2010, 4:07 PM MST, anonymous wrote:
The principles of the V motor on your website are related to the following technology.
I know that the claims of Kedron have been verified by other parties. I think there is a very good chance the V motor works. I do know that Clanzer has not successfully replicated it yet.
NOTE: We are presently moderating all
comments, to keep out the crass negativity, flaming, and other
inappropriate forms of criticism. We welcome constructive
criticism tactfully stated. Frequent offenders will be
"It is harder to crack a prejudice than an atom." // "I'd rather be an optimist and a fool than a pessimist and
right." -- Albert Einstein
ADVISORY: With any
technology, you take a high risk to invest significant time or money
unless (1) independent testing has thoroughly corroborated the
technology, (2) the group involved has intellectual rights to the
technology, and (3) the group has the ability to make a success of
truth passes through three stages:
First, it is ridiculed;
Second, it is violently opposed; and
Third, it is accepted as self-evident.
Arthur Schopenhauer (1788-1860)
"When you're one step ahead
of the crowd you're a genius.
When you're two steps ahead,
you're a crackpot."